Butcher's Crossing vs Pembroke: Which Should You Read?

Both live on shelves: Literature - Classics, Literary, Classics, Fiction

Butcher's Crossing John Williams · 1960 ★★★★☆ 4.2 265 pages · ≈ 4 h 54 m · Challenging

In the 1870s, Will Andrews, fired up by Emerson to seek "an original relation to nature," drops out of Harvard and heads west. He washes up in Butcher's Crossing, a small Kansas town full of restless men looking for…

1 film adaptation

Fiction - General Westerns

Find on Amazon More like this →

Pembroke Mary Eleanor Wilkins Freeman · 1894 ★★★★☆ 3.9 330 pages · ≈ 6 h 07 m · Demanding

"Pembroke begins with a heated political argument between Barney Thayer and Cephas Barnard, the father of Barney's betrothed, Charlotte Barnard. The angry Cephas throws his prospective son-in-law out of the house and,…

19th Century Fiction Villages New england Psychological fiction

Find on Amazon More like this →

Side by side

The verdict

Readers rate Butcher's Crossing highest: Butcher's Crossing 4.2 · Pembroke 3.9.
Butcher's Crossing has the widest readership — 42893 ratings behind its score.
Pembroke runs the darker storyline; Butcher's Crossing stays the lighter read.

How to choose

New to the genre? Butcher's Crossing Challenging vs Demanding for Pembroke In the mood for something dark? Pembroke a darker storyline than Butcher's Crossing Want something lighter? Butcher's Crossing an easier tone than Pembroke

Scores by source

	Butcher's Crossing	Pembroke
Goodreads	4.2 (42893)	3.9 (59)
Hardcover	4.1 (147)	—
Google Books	5.0 (1)	—
Apple Books	4.0 (106)	—

Reception

	Butcher's Crossing	Pembroke
Ratings	42893	59
Editions	12	31
Film adaptations	1	1
Want to read	—	94
Reading it now	—	5
Written reviews	—	7
Wikipedia attention	8926	88
Pages	265	330

Questions readers ask

Which is rated higher: Butcher's Crossing or Pembroke?

Butcher's Crossing has the higher combined reader rating across sources (Butcher's Crossing 4.2/5, Pembroke 3.9/5).

Which is shorter to read: Butcher's Crossing or Pembroke?

Butcher's Crossing is the quickest read. Estimated at 225 words per minute: Butcher's Crossing (265 pages, ≈ 4 h 54 m); Pembroke (330 pages, ≈ 6 h 07 m).

Which is harder to read: Butcher's Crossing or Pembroke?

Estimated difficulty, based on era, reader shelves and length — Butcher's Crossing: Challenging; Pembroke: Demanding.

Have both books been made into films?

Butcher's Crossing: 4 film adaptations; Pembroke: no film adaptation on record.