Heartbreak Hotel vs I am Charlotte Simmons: Which Should You Read?
Both live on shelves: Women college students, Race Relations, Bildungsromans, Fiction
Heartbreak Hotel
“The making of Maggie Deloach was a process as indigenous to her part of the South as the making of cotton textiles in the fortress-bricked mills that crouched over the muddy, fast-moving rivers of the Georgia and Alabama plateau country.”
Bestselling author Siddons brings to life the long, hot summer of 1956, when everyone was singing Elvis Presley's hit single. Maggie is a sorority girl, the quintessential Southern young lady--until she meets two people…
vs
I am Charlotte Simmons
“Every time the men's-room door opened, the amped-up onslaught of Swarm, the band banging out the concert in the theater overhead , came crashing in, ricocheting off all the mirrors and ceramic surfaces until it seemed twice as loud.”
"Dupont University - the Olympian halls of learning housing the cream of America's youth, the roseate Gothic spires and manicured lawns suffused with tradition... Or so it appears to beautiful, brilliant Charlotte…
The verdict
- Readers rate Heartbreak Hotel highest: Heartbreak Hotel 3.8 · I am Charlotte Simmons 3.5.
- Heartbreak Hotel is the quickest read — about 5 hours vs 12 for I am Charlotte Simmons.
- Heartbreak Hotel has the widest readership — 32645 ratings behind its score.
Scores by source
| Heartbreak Hotel | I am Charlotte Simmons | |
|---|---|---|
| Goodreads | 3.8 (32645) | 3.5 (28650) |
| Hardcover | 4.0 (2) | — |
| Apple Books | — | 4.0 (92) |
Reception
| Heartbreak Hotel | I am Charlotte Simmons | |
|---|---|---|
| Ratings | 32645 | 28650 |
| Editions | 12 | 31 |
| Film adaptations | 1 | 1 |
| Want to read | 68099 | — |
| Reading it now | 1051 | — |
| Written reviews | 5495 | — |
| Wikipedia attention | 164 | 1328 |
| Pages | 314 | 676 |