The Remains of an Altar (Merrily Watkins Mysteries) vs The smile of a ghost: Which Should You Read?

Cover of The Remains of an Altar (Merrily Watkins Mysteries) The Remains of an Altar (Merrily Watkins Mysteries) Phil Rickman · 2006 ★★★★☆ 3.8 544 pages · ≈ 10 h 04 m · Moderate

"In 1934, the dying composer Sir Edward Elgar feebly whistled to a friend the theme from his Cello Concerto and said, "If you're walking on the Malvern Hills and hear that, don't be frightened. It's only me." Seventy…

vs
Cover of The smile of a ghost The smile of a ghost Phil Rickman · 2005 ★★★★☆ 4.3 544 pages · ≈ 10 h 04 m · Moderate

The border town of Ludlow has it all: exquisite medieval streets, an imposing ruined castle, a parish church the size of a cathedral and a weight of history and legend. Wealthy people, famous people, have come to Ludlow…

1★2★3★4★5★

The verdict

Scores by source

The Remains of an Altar (Merrily Watkins Mysteries)The smile of a ghost
Goodreads — 4.3 (1866)
Hardcover 3.3 (3) 3.3 (3)

Reception

The Remains of an Altar (Merrily Watkins Mysteries)The smile of a ghost
Ratings 3 1866
Editions 8 10
Want to read — 581
Reading it now — 48
Written reviews — 112
Pages 544 544

Side by side

The Remains of an Altar (Merrily Watkins Mysteries)The smile of a ghostEnjoymentDifficultyInfluencePopularityClassic

Shared themes